The Secrets of J Dilla
J Dilla is one of music's great innovators. I'm sharing my analysis of 12 of his songs, and I think I have new insight to share. I was struggling to hear millisecond-level detail, so I built an app specifically for this, called Practice Room.
Intro
J Dilla is one of the architects of modern music. His timefeel was a critical influence on D'Angelo, Questlove, et. al, culminating in the landmark album Voodoo. Their work still continues to impact modern music, 25 years later. So what exactly was Dilla's timefeel?
I found that J Dilla builds swing across drum voices, where each voice contributes to the swing feel, lengthening and shortening their respective parts of the beat. The placement of his bass, and the placement of his 16th note kick pickups also characterize his timefeel.
1: The mechanics of the rushed snare: additive inter-voice swing
The demo below is one beat of Raise It Up. I nudged the hi-hat, snare, and kick to be totally straight. When you click through, you can see how adjusting the placement of each of the voices shortens and lengthens the respective parts of the beat.
So when J Dilla was adjusting the microtiming of his drums, I believe that underneath, he was building swing cumulatively across the hi-hat, kick, and snare.
J Dilla builds swing with the HH, kick, and snare, on Raise It Up
2: The drums arrive first
Check out how late the bass arrives after the drums. For example, on So Far To Go, somtimes he lays the bass back even longer than a 32nd note past the downbeat.
How late does the bass arrive after the drums?
bass vs the groove's beats, median lateness per track in milliseconds.
3: How much does Dilla really swing his hi-hats?
Sometimes on Instagram, you'll see someone playing a 'Dilla feel' with a drastically swung hi-hat. That's probably an exagerration, or misunderstanding of Dilla's timefeel. In the songs I'm studying here, his hats are fairly straight - between 50 to 52% swing mostly.
Hi-hat swing alone vs. the cumulative/felt swing
Open circle: hats swing. Filled: the felt/cumulative swing, the median per track, its number printed beside the dot . Diamond: hi-hat swing (16ths: the e/a vs the 8th positions). The two controls at the bottom are played, not programmed: Questlove on Chicken Grease, James Gadson on Sugah Daddy.
4: Underlying 16th note swing - the "a" of 4
Check out how much Dilla swings the kick's pickup sixteenths. He builds a cumulative 8th note swing feel as I've shown above, and builds another underlying swing feel for the 16ths.
The kick's pickup sixteenths swing percentages. Tracks with no kick pickups are left out.
5: Conclusion
I hope this gave you new insight into how Dilla wove together time and rhythm like an architect - his timefeel and swing built across every instrument, meticulously. His artistry continues to inspire me and so many others.
Try Practice Room
Get the groove analyzer for yourself, with Practice Room. Drop in a song, make a selection, right click and hit Analyze Groove. It generates the exact same player and analysis at the top of this study. 11-stem splitting lets you measure each of the drum voices down to the millisecond. You can also slow it down, change pitch, and mute whichever track you want to help practice with the record.
The records
A note about why I included each song, and also which section of the song I'm showcasing.